It's Official: These Are the Best Drugstore Foundations for Oily Skin

Foundation is tricky—and by tricky, we mean somewhat overwhelming. Though we’re constantly trying new, complexion-enhancing formulas on our T-zones and cheekbones, we still routinely find ourselves in the middle of a makeup aisle, scratching our heads, throwing up our hands, and slowly backing away toward the door.

After all, there are numerous factors that beg careful consideration. From shade to price to formulation, what works for some won’t necessarily work for others—especially if you have oily skin. For this skin type, you need a formula that won’t act like a Slip ‘n Slide after a few hours of wear. To lend a helping hand, we consulted celebrity makeup artist Tobi Henney and narrowed down the selection to the very best drugstore foundation formulas for those prone to oily skin and blemishes.

Keep reading for the best drugstore foundations for oily skin.

Best Overall:
Neutrogena SkinClearing Liquid Makeup

Buy On Ulta
Buy On Target

Coverage: Medium | Shade Range: 8 | Finish: Soft Matte | Size: 1 fl. oz.

Heavy, cake-prone foundations don’t do skin any favors for those prone to bumps and inflammation. So, by incorporating an acne-fighting formula designed especially for oily skin types, you can beat breakouts before they happen in the first place. This drugstore foundation from Almay contains salicylic acid to treat current breakouts and prevent future ones while concealing blemishes, controlling shine, and minimizing pores. More importantly, the lightweight formula does so while letting your skin breathe.

Best for Excess Shine:
Catrice HD Liquid Coverage Foundation

Buy On Amazon
Buy On Ulta

Coverage: Full | Shade Range: 26 | Finish: Matte | Size: 1 fl. oz.

If you have oily skin, then you’re well aware of the struggle it is to stay shine-free throughout the day. That’s why we’re big fans of this foundation from Catrice. It completely conceals imperfections and creates a smooth, ultra-matte finish that lasts up to 24 hours. Plus it’s lightweight and oil-free, making it a great option for acne-prone types too. Blotting sheets, who?

The 10 Best Drugstore BB Creams for an Airbrushed Finish

Best Long-Wear:
L’Oréal Paris Infallible Pro-Matte Foundation

Buy On Ulta
Buy On Walmart

Coverage: Medium | Shade Range: 22 | Finish: Matte | Size: 1 fl. oz.

There’s a reason this drugstore foundation makes each and every “best of” list when it comes to formulas designed for oily skin. “It has a great formulation that helps to avoid oil buildup throughout the day,” says Henney. Even a light-handed application yields a flattering, demi-matte finish that promises to withstand the test of time—as in a full 24 hours.

These Are the Very Best Liquid Foundations—Trust Us

Best Lightweight:
Rimmel London Stay Matte Liquid Mousse Foundation

Buy On Amazon
Buy On Ulta
Buy On Nyxcosmetics.com

Coverage: Full | Shade Range: 45 | Finish: Matte | Size: 1 fl. oz.

Henney counts this foundation from NYX as another one of her drugstore favorites. “This is such an inexpensive foundation that’s great for everyday wear,” she says. “I love that the formula will cover any redness, acne, and pigmentation.” Best of all? It’s available in a whopping 45 shades, meaning 24-hour matte, full-coverage for all.

16 Drugstore Concealers That Rival Their More Expensive Counterparts

Best for Dark Skin:
Black Opal True Color Mineral Matte Crème Powder Foundation SPF 15

Buy On Riteaid.com
Buy On Target

Coverage: Medium | Shade Range: 12 | Finish: Matte | Size: 0.3 oz.

Oily skin is no match for this cream-to-powder foundation. It mattifies the skin to keep shine at bay while nourishing it with non-greasy ingredients like aloe and vitamins C and E. The result is a smooth, velvety finish that never looks or feels dry. Created specifically for those with melanin-rich skin, it’s available in a number of shades that flatter medium to deep skin tones—plus, it uses special shade ID technology with multi-colored chromatic pigments that adjust to your unique skin tone to get your perfect match. Did we mention it also contains SPF?

Best for Medium Skin:
Juvia’s Place I Am Magic Foundation

Buy On Ulta

Coverage: Full | Shade Range: 35 | Finish: Soft Matte | Size: 1 fl. oz.

Another brand known for always offering an inclusive shade range, this Juvia’s Place foundation has an extensive number of options for medium, olive, and tan skin tones. As the name suggests, the formula is truly magic. It evens out the complexion while refining skin texture and erasing blemishes, leaving behind a soft matte finish that feels natural. Even better? It stays put all day long.

Best for Light Skin:
Makeup Revolution Conceal & Define Full Coverage Foundation

Buy On Ulta
Buy On Revolutionbeauty.us
Buy On Skinstore.com

Coverage: Full | Shade Range: 42 | Finish: Demi-Matte | Size: 0.8 fl. oz.

We love how effortlessly this lightweight, buildable foundation from Catrice diffuses blemishes and redness without feeling too heavy or cakey. It boasts a pretty impressive shade range, including tons of options for even the fairest of skin tones—the range even includes a pure white lightening shade so you can create your perfect custom color. It’s oil-free yet super creamy, so you can trust it’s comfortable but won’t slide off before the end of the day. Plus, it features a built-in jumbo doe foot applicator for mess-free (and less wasteful) application.

Best Full Coverage:
CoverGirl TruBlend Matte Made Liquid Foundation

Buy On Ulta

Coverage: Full | Shade Range: 36 | Finish: Soft Matte | Size: 1 fl. oz.

When it comes to full-coverage foundations, the last thing you want is to feel like you’re wearing a mask—especially a dry, cakey mask. That’s why we’re major fans of this Covergirl foundation. It creates a flexible, comfortable layer over the skin that conceals imperfections and keeps oil under control for up to 12 hours. The result? Soft, smooth, and absolutely flawless skin.

The 19 Best Full-Coverage Makeup Products Out There

Best Medium Coverage:
Revlon ColorStay Makeup For Combination/Oily Skin SPF 15

Buy On Amazon
Buy On Ulta

Coverage: Medium to Full | Shade Range: 16 | Finish: Matte | Size: 1 fl. oz.

A favorite of senior editor Lindsey Metrus, this foundation stays in place even on the hottest, sweatiest days. And even though it’s a bit thicker on contact, when applied with a Beautyblender, it buffs seamlessly into the skin and can be built upon for fuller coverage. “It’s super blendable,” says Henney. “I also love that it has SPF—it’s the perfect foundation for oily skin as we enter summer.”

Best Light Coverage:
Undone Beauty Matte Tint Foundation

Buy On Target

Coverage: Light | Shade Range: 8 | Finish: Matte | Size: 1.13 fl. oz.

Many light coverage foundations tend to lean towards the dewier side, which typically isn’t a great match for oily types. However, that’s not the case for this tinted foundation from Undone Beauty. It provides just enough coverage to conceal imperfections while leaving behind a natural matte finish that’s soft and smooth. Bonus? It’s formulated with tea tree oil to keep oil and blemishes at bay throughout the day.

Best Stick:
Maybelline New York Fit Me Shine-Free + Balance Stick Foundation

Buy On Amazon
Buy On Maybelline.com
Buy On Walmart

Coverage: Medium | Shade Range: 12 | Finish: Natural Matte | Size: .32 oz.

The long-lost (yet equally effective) cousin to its liquid-foundation counterpart, Maybelline’s beloved Fit Me foundation also comes in an easy-to-transport stick formulation we can’t stop tossing into our purse. Yes, it strategically discourages shine, but the medium coverage is also great for blending away redness in a soothing manner that never disrupts our skin’s homeostasis. 

Final Verdict

If you have oily skin, a foundation that tackles excess shine and won’t clog your pores will be your best friend. That’s why we love Neutrogena’s SkinClearing Liquid Makeup, an oil-free, non-comedogenic (aka non-clogging) foundation that features a special microclear technology with salicylic acid to address shine, blemishes, and redness. Plus, it leaves behind a gorgeous natural finish that’s not too dewy or too matte. Next up, L’Oréal’s Paris Infallible Pro-Matte Foundation is a fan-favorite for good reason. It leaves behind a flawless matte (read: not flat) finish and prevents oil from building up throughout the day, resisting sweat, heat, and humidity for up to 24 hours. And finally, Undone Beauty’s Matte Tint Foundation is great for achieving an effortless no-makeup makeup look sans greasiness. It offers a hint of coverage with a non-dewy matte finish. Plus, it’s formulated with tea tree oil to keep oil and blemishes at bay.

What to Look for in a Foundation for Oily Skin

An Oil-Free Formula

If you have oily skin, products that contain oil aren’t necessarily the enemy—in fact, there are plenty of facial oils suitable for oily and acne-prone skin types. However, when it comes to foundation, Henney says it’s best to leave it behind. Oil-free formulas tend to be lighter in weight and will prevent your skin from looking shiny and greasy as the day goes on. Many foundations do contain oil, so be sure to look for products that specifically indicate they’re free of it. 

A Non-Comedogenic Formula

Another keyword Henney recommends oily types look out for is “non-comedogenic.” Non-comedogenic formulas won’t clog your pores, which helps to prevent breakouts and enlarged pores, keeping your complexion nice and clear. Remember, non-comedogenic and oil-free aren’t necessarily interchangeable terms, so look for products that specify they’re both.

A Matte Finish

Unfortunately, the ever-popular dewy look isn’t suitable for those with oily skin, especially if you’re prone to looking shinier throughout the day. That’s why Henney recommends opting for formulas with matte finishes. “Those with oily skin never want to add more shine to their skin—matte options work much better,” she says. That doesn’t necessarily mean you need to opt for the flattest matte out there, demi-matte and natural matte finishes are also good options.

Meet the Expert

Tobi Henney is a bi-coastal makeup artist known for creating flawless, glowing skin. Her celebrity clientele includes the likes of Megan Fox and Ashley Graham and her work can be seen across the ad campaigns of major brands and in the editorials of the top fashion magazines. She originally hails from Sydney, where she was previously the L’Oréal Paris Makeup Director for Australia.

The Ultimate Guide to Finding the Perfect Foundation