Eyeliner vs. Mascara: The Final Information to Choosing the Proper One for Your Look


Close up of a woman wearing subtle eyeliner and mascara

If you happen to put on eye make-up, we all know you have obtained all types of mascaras and eyeliners rolling round in your make-up bag. (Effectively, a minimum of, that is true for us.) They every have their place in your routine relying on the look you are carving out. However have you ever ever puzzled which of the 2 the consultants would use, for instance, to present the phantasm of wider or extra upturned eyes?

We requested professional make-up artists Jeanine Lobell and Shadi Malek to interrupt down the how-tos of utilizing mascara and eyeliner for a number of of the commonest eye make-up considerations. They shared not solely which product is greatest for getting the look, but in addition use the dynamic eye make-up duo collectively. (As a result of spoiler alert: More often than not, they use each.) Learn on to study extra.


01of 04

Finest for: Making Your Eyes Look Wider

A photo of Covergirl's Lash Blast Mascara in an orange tube
CoverGirl Lash Blast Quantity Mascara $5.00

We have all seen gorgeous photographs of icons like Twiggy, Diana Ross, and Cher the place their eyes pop. Lashes are one approach to recreate their iconic seems. However how will we make our eyes seem wider with eyeliner and mascara? And to take it a step additional, which of the 2 is best at creating the phantasm of wider eyes? Effectively, you possibly can in all probability guess what our consultants suggest, however we’ll allow them to let you know about their preferences.

“I discover including further mascara within the heart of the lashes can actually open and carry,” says Lobell. “Suppose Cher along with her starry lashes. Focus the mascara on the middle.” Mainly, it is all about placement.

Whereas mascara is all it is advisable create wider eyes, if you wish to take issues up a notch an eyeliner pencil is the next step. You may assume your reply is a white liner (properly, a minimum of that is what I believed). Nonetheless, it is all about discovering your nude, particularly if you happen to’re searching for a extra doe-eyed impact.

Malek says the shade you will need to go together with can even be dictated by how vast you need your eyes to look. “Once I need a softer look, I take advantage of brown eyeshadow in comparison with once I need a extra dramatic look,” she says; she recommends a black gel eyeliner if you wish to amp up the drama.

02of 04

Finest For: Making Your Eyes Look Longer

Photo of Neen Side Eye Liner
Neen Facet Eye Liner $19.00

With regards to making the eyes look longer, Lobell often reaches for a black liner pencil. “I first take the pencil and add black within the high waterline and into the internal nook. Subsequent, I take the tip of the pencil, touchdown it on the outer nook of the attention—like under lashes the place the highest meets the underside—and simply flick it straight out, lifting upward just a little. This sort of connects the entire line from the internal nook out, creating an look of width.” After all, to place the following tips to make use of, Lobell says a sharpened tip is a should.

Photo of LANCÔME's Hypnôse 8 Mascara
Lancôme Le 8 Hypnôse Mascara $32.00

Now as a result of this may be achieved with mascara as properly, we will share these expert-approved methods, too. “With mascara, I recommend beginning the appliance within the outer lashes,” Lobell says. “Do not forget that wherever you begin your software, you’ll deposit probably the most product. Utilizing the tip of the mascara brush, I actually attempt to get these tinier outer nook lashes first, then I transfer towards the middle of the attention. I do not put an excessive amount of on the lashes towards the internal nook. As soon as I’ve coated the lashes, I shortly add a second coat to the lashes on the outer nook.”

03of 04

Finest For: Making Your Eyes Look Extra Upturned

Photo of Hyper Easy Liquid Pen Eyeliner
Maybelline Hyper Straightforward Liquid Pen Eyeliner $8.00

If you have not heard, siren eyes are trending. For a extra upturned-eye look, Malek suggests a staple: black eyeliner. “To create siren eyes, the very best trick is to make use of both a gel pot or a liquid eyeliner and wing out the tip of your eyeliner, ensuring to depart a spot throughout the center of your eyelid after which making a pointed internal nook to make the attention seem longer.” To have just a little extra enjoyable, she suggests a coloured liquid liner or eyeshadow; we like Danessa Myricks’ Waterproof Cushion Liner ($15) in Completely Tangerine or Cheekbone Magnificence’s Maintain Eyeshadow Pencil ($24) in Sky Blue. Simply maintain a q-tip and micellar water close by to wash up any errors.

04of 04

Finest for: Making Your Eyes Look Extra Awake

Photo of Ilia mascara
ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara $28.00

We have all been there: You bought no sleep, however in some way it is advisable seem awake. This can be a job for one magnificence important—mascara. Nonetheless, Lobell needs you to skip your backside lashes. “I might focus mascara primarily on the highest as a result of the underside may draw extra focus to a ‘drained’ look,” she says. One different useful product, although “mascara is your good friend,” as Lobell put it, is a flesh-toned coloured pencil or liquid liner to take out any redness.

Moreover, Lobell suggests beginning out by curling your eyelashes pre-mascara and choosing a light-weight method (her favourite is Illia’s Limitless Lash). “Maintain the roller in place for a second or two after which go in with the mascara, coating it twice on the root after which brushing upward so it is darkest by your eye,” she says. “That can make your eyes look their perkiest and [most] awake.”

Leave a reply